Google
網誌排行 top-bloggers.com
About this Entry
Posted by: hystericireul

Visit hystericireul's Xanga Site

Original: 5/25/2009 9:32 AM
Views: 469
Comments: 25
eProps: 40

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site

Monday, May 25, 2009

無用之用

 

在一個聚會上跟朋友談起近況,他是個虔誠的教徒,剛完成了音樂碩士的他打算再讀個神學碩士。

常常從外國的朋友聽到不少「奇人異士」的故事,他們的經歷,從「香港價值」來衡量,可謂混帳之至。有人先讀了個工程學士,然後再讀生物碩士、建築碩士,再來個哲學博士,神學博士,然後周遊列國,四處探求世界真理。不那麼「奇」的是有些人讀的學士跟碩士跟工作可謂三碼子不同的範疇,卻能好好運用各科不同的知識。

我想,也許這才是我們「通識」的真義吧。香港許是生活節奏太快了吧,都容不下「無用」之學,殊不知這令我們的世界都顯得比別人偏狹,讓「智慧」本身降了格,以至「知識」也談不上,得到只是「技能」,更甚者,所得莫過一張「沙紙」而已。

白宮幕僚長伊曼紐爾年輕時曾當過芭蕾舞員,後來卻政經兩棲,大放異彩。在香港我們會有這種職業流動性嗎?我們都有太多的成見,太少的創見,總喜歡將人定形,而「沙紙」就是定形的利器,你讀過語文你必然不懂得財金之技,不食人間煙火,你曾當過老師便必然是溫室中的花王,不諳世途險惡。

這不能不說是十分諷刺的事。知識原本應該是打破隔閡,打破成見的利器,到頭來卻成了我們用沙紙堆砌的囹圄。知識原本應是擴闊我們眼界的窗子,到頭來卻成了觀天的幼管。

更諷刺的是現在教育界推行的「通識教育」。整個社會都講求單一,講求表面的學科名字,追逐越來越嚇唬人的名稱,而不求內在的知識,不要求打通各科的「任督二脈」,然後卻來推行這「通識教育」,不啻一種黑色幽默。沒有這種社會氛圍,再多通識也枉然。有這種氛圍,卻也不用阿茂來整餅。也許最根本的原因是,我們無法改變如石頭一樣的社會人士,只好向還未變得頑固的學生開刀。一方面要學生「通識」,一方面社會卻歧視通識,簡直將學生當作傻子。

許是這種喜歡論斷人,喜歡定形別人的氣氛太過討厭,我也實在有種「吾不欲觀之」的無力感。大概越來越多人厭倦這種只顧衝衝衝而失去了生活的社會,現在香港越來越多人奉行「吾不育,觀之」的哲學,不生育孩子,冷眼看著這城沉淪。

 Posted 5/25/2009 9:32 AM - 469 Views - 40 eProps - 25 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

25 Comments

Visit bigarnex's Xanga Site!

I'm at school now ... so gonna comment in English. Seriously I can identify with what you are writing here. I once blogged about being asked about my age in almost routinely in Korea. I kind of hate to answer because I fear that the following question would be "Why are you still studying at 30-something?" (that is the typical reaction in Hong Kong I guess) But in fact, I very seldom get that.


Well, I guess, it MIGHT be a problem if I finish university and CONTINUE studying and never work until I am 30 something. But having worked for almost 10 years, I think it is actually a good time to go back to school to get your knowledge organized and strengthened. Sometimes, I feel it is really hard to explain this to people in Hong Kong... so I can kind of identify with what you write here.

Posted 5/25/2009 10:12 AM by bigarnex Xanga True Member - reply

Visit antong85's Xanga Site!
這篇寫得真好。

早前我也想讀個中文碩士,但遭到身邊的人反對,
說讀來做什麼,教書嗎?反正文學這東西在香港也不值錢。叫我不如將來讀個MBA罷。
更諷刺的是連一位讀教育的準老師竟然也和我說同一番說話,我都不知香港的下一代到底會變成怎樣。

唉,到底香港有多少人明白「大學」是一處什麼地方呢?
如果我們進大學只為了得到一些「職業技能」,為什麼不乾脆叫職業訓練局開班就算了?

我也真的十分討厭別人說我讀文科便是要去教書,要去做記者...
我只是想說很多文學院的同學都是有智慧、有深度的人....並非大家說得那麼一無是處啊!讀經濟、讀建築、讀工程便一定比較優越嗎?到底什麼時候我們才能有多一點的空間呢?我真是恨極一堆井底之蛙...
Posted 5/25/2009 10:53 AM by antong85 - reply

Visit Feheart's Xanga Site!
好文推推(雖然xanga 係無得推)

自己本身也不希望被人"定形"......但在香港"定不了形"的人=無用
我就是這麼一個無用之人......
Posted 5/25/2009 11:07 AM by Feheart - reply

Visit runnamiao's Xanga Site!
十分十分認同
選科得時候經常被人問:讀來有甚麼用?
早前選了這課比較像文化研究和fine art的科時
就有同學覺得不夠專而放棄

剛好我昨天坐了一份作業和這主題有關
如果有空就去看看吧:
http://mobile-runnamiao.blogspot.com/2009/05/comtemporary-art-assignment-3-new.html
Posted 5/25/2009 11:19 AM by runnamiao - reply

Visit CheriCherish's Xanga Site!

Yesterday, when I told my friend that I plan to quit my work and spend half year in Beijing to learn Madarin next year. He told me it's better to stay on  stable job and save more money. Yes, maybe he is logical, realistic. I am such a non realistic person.


Maybe in HK, only few people are qualified to talk about dream. And I am those non qualified to talk about dream. It costs me some time to accept the fact.

Posted 5/25/2009 11:36 AM by CheriCherish - reply

Visit adrianlu1026's Xanga Site!
咁你明白讀社科係一回咩事啦?好聽係乜都識,唔好聽係乜都唔識。
Posted 5/25/2009 11:36 AM by adrianlu1026 - reply

Visit pineapplesam's Xanga Site!
與通識唔通識無關既…… 什麼人支錢在教育,就會得出什麼教育來。因為他們是大客。香港整個教育制度也是受制於這些「家長」,也不只是通識科混帳。

"現在香港來越多人奉行「吾不育,觀之」的哲學,不生育孩子,冷眼看著這城沉淪。" 我覺得現在這世代決定生孩子的人也很勇敢的說……
Posted 5/25/2009 11:51 AM by pineapplesam - reply

Visit maple_autumn's Xanga Site!

@Feheart - 正文下方,留言上方有個長方框,第一個功能就是「recommend」,在紅心上按一下就可推文。


真羨慕文中的奇人啊,我會以他們為學習目標。

Posted 5/25/2009 12:19 PM by maple_autumn Xanga True Member - reply

Visit euyak's Xanga Site!
「吾不育,觀之」
呢句真係笑咗,好中。

的確,好多人大學揀科時已經以「畢業揾咩工」為大前提
Posted 5/25/2009 12:23 PM by euyak - reply

Visit euyak's Xanga Site!
「我也真的十分討厭別人說我讀文科便是要去教書,要去做記者...」
讀理科都係俾人問「你去教書?」......
Posted 5/25/2009 12:24 PM by euyak - reply

Visit alienchans69's Xanga Site!

「學歷至上,知識無用。」就是他們的座右銘吧。


Posted 5/25/2009 12:31 PM by alienchans69 - reply

Visit bigarnex's Xanga Site!
越看這些comment就越怕回不來了。
Posted 5/25/2009 1:04 PM by bigarnex Xanga True Member - reply

Visit Affliction_Man's Xanga Site!
在香港,就算學富五車,上知天文,下知地理,
賺唔到$都沒有用.
唉~這是一個$$$$的世界~
Posted 5/25/2009 1:14 PM by Affliction_Man - reply

Visit tommyjonk's Xanga Site!
HY,人家的看法,你管得了嗎?

所謂君子不器,最重要知道自己真是恪守中道而行。

不要氣餒,愈沉淪的社會,愈需要我們繼續努力呀!
Posted 5/25/2009 2:32 PM by tommyjonk Xanga True Member - reply

Visit CYLM's Xanga Site!
好好好!!! 支持!!! 你也不要气馁,加油, 走自己想走的路!!! :)
Posted 5/25/2009 4:42 PM by CYLM - reply

Visit rabbitobaggio's Xanga Site!
這是文科生特別深刻的一種感悟吧...
Posted 5/25/2009 4:49 PM by rabbitobaggio - reply

Visit yychanlyann's Xanga Site!

愈看便愈覺得可怕,我是一個沒有專長只有好奇心的大學生,很辛苦的得了個學位,才發現失去了目標。


沙紙已有一張,HIGHER DIPLOMER in一半工程一半設計。


明知讀工程一定有飯開,卻又不想放棄夢想,浪費了幾千元的留位費,傻嗎?


社會與我各有答案。


事實是過兩年後我也要吃飯還錢。

Posted 5/25/2009 9:05 PM by yychanlyann - reply

Visit room5050's Xanga Site!
well said....
小學同學都在讀音樂博士了 而我大學至今都還沒畢業
可能是努力加上運氣 在紐約服製業得以生存
諷刺的是 現在的工作是學校沒教的 是自己在工作中摸索出來的
我很幸運的得到這些知識 甚至讓我更加相信 知識的證明不在一紙學歷
今天我可以回去學校把本科學業完成 但我知道工作已經教我比學校還要多的東西
我已經可以轉移陣地 去追求不一樣的知識了
這讓我知道 知識和人生道路是有他自己的伸展性 也是多變的
但要跨出那一步去抓住他 是要一筆可觀的勇氣

曾經和朋友聊過 亞洲的父母是沒辦法讓他們的孩子走上和我一樣的路
這場人生的賭注太大了
今天要是我沒走好 我不過是那些父母口中的失敗者
Posted 5/26/2009 5:18 AM by room5050 - reply

Visit twchau's Xanga Site!
I guess Hong Kong people, maybe as well as in other East Asian culture, tend to have very high psychological cost in changing tract and starting over late, or not to utilize one's qualification. It is regarded as foolish to quit a PhD program, or take a year break without being kicked out. It is also regarded as foolish to get a job after graduation that doesn't make use the qualification, unless you can't. I am a bit lost and unhappy now, but to be frank, I dare not change the track.

About general (liberal) education, I always doubt how/whether secondary school teacher can judge the quality of arguments without resorting to their own judgment of the issue. Will Hui Po Keung and Francis Lui mutually fail each others' arguments? Together with the competitive pressure to higher education, where evaluation is important, such change will only raise the degree of subjectivity and hurt the perceived fairness of the system. Moreover, at secondary school stage, to what extent should we want them to learn something (facts, skills and values) that is generally true, and to what extent we want them to critically criticize the established views? We may always worry that the latter will get the students out of control and challenge everything, including the peaceful order, and anything we want them to learn. Will this power of challenge disable us to impose any standard to students?
Posted 5/26/2009 6:33 AM by twchau - reply

Visit galileo_c's Xanga Site!
尚算好彩,本來家人完全唔明我讀咩,依家阿爸想讀埋一份,不過唔識英文,無計。

教新傳的老世有日講開通識,由思考談到宗教緣由,再想起之前班上同學為份教案做到不上不下,灰。
Posted 5/29/2009 4:40 AM by galileo_c - reply

Visit hystericireul's Xanga Site!

@bigarnex - It's really difficult to go back to school in the 30s. Cause in HK, we have to struggle for living and canot bear any freedom to have further studies. For an ordinary HKer, in the 30s, they have to support the family and raise the children, I really see no other exits...... Until the children grown up.


@antong85 - 香港現在空談「通識」,卻全然沒有這種通識的氣氛,我真的覺得非常諷刺,悲涼地可笑。以前在文學院,除了以上的有色眼鏡外,甚至還有些人會認為我們學的都「只是吹水」,那我們還能說些甚麼呢。


@Feheart - 你讀那科算好的了吧,最少可以在「定形」以糊口之餘,尋找其他的可能。我想這是我們唯一的出路吧。


@runnamiao - 挺有趣的,但我想如果我來作的話會更「盡」一點呢。每個學生都急不及待地要令自己「專」起來,只鑽研容易找工作容易糊口的技能,難怪我們越來越多技能,越來越少知識。


@CheriCherish - Honestly, I think girls in HK do have more choices than boys. Boys need more time and money to plan for future, while it is not a must for a girl to prepare them all to marry or to plan. Other than that, you have to be born in a real wealthy family to support your dream.


I hope I can be qualified to have a dream by the age of 40. But that's not easy at all.


@adrianlu1026 - 而讀文學院,就係:好聽係乜都唔識,唔好聽都係乜都唔識。


@pineapplesam - 對,家長所思所想不一定比老師和業者的好,尤其是經過香港社會的嚴重污染之後。


有些事情,是應該從賢不從眾的,就像某些政策的制定一樣。現在的香港就是這樣:授權給老師之後又指手劃腳,同時推卸自己的責任。


@maple_autumn - 我也羨慕,但我想我只能停留在羨慕的層次了,或最多找個折衷的辦法。


@euyak - 基本上純文純理都是這樣。很討厭這樣。


@alienchans69 - 大家也是過台戲而已,有張沙紙是最快捷的證明。


@Affliction_Man - 我想,學富五車而賺不到錢這不是問題,問題是社會本身不尊重知識和智慧,這便很有問題了。


@tommyjonk - 謝老師!


上次看到John的文章,心中也隱然覺得,寫的東西好像都在來回打轉,而看不到有甚麼改進和轉變。所以有時我想轉個口味,改多作藝評影評算了。


但最後還是老樣子。


@CYLM - 謝謝!你好像現在在外面讀書吧?你的魄力很叫人尊敬呢!


@rabbitobaggio - 對,尤其是在HKU,學生都更多白眼,更多標籤,實在令人感到疲累。


@yychanlyann - 其實我自工作以來已很快磨蝕了夢想,我寧願在工作以外再尋找這東西。


@room5050 - 恭喜你能尋到自己的路向呢!


@twchau - I think we need some "basic knowledge" before we criticize. These "basic knowledge" are so important that they build up a framework for us to criticize the world. However, as the education always stress on criticism and ONLY criticism only, nowadays, I see branch of students criticize WITHOUT ANY LOGICAL ARGUMENT.


On the other hand, to strike a balance between creativity and logical thinking (on-track thinking?) is really difficult. The story of 陶傑 and 鄧飛 make me think of an even older story happened in China in the cultural revolution: a student did not answer the Public Exam Paper, but just wrote "無產階級萬歲,毛主席萬歲" and also criticize the examinor as one of the murderer of capitalism. And then, although he actually answer nothing related with the paper, he got 1st in the exam.


I can't help myself think of this story when I read the newspaper, I must say I do not have a solution on "Liberal Studies".


@galileo_c - 其實我都唔太明你讀咩...... 不如有機會你同我講多次~~~~

Posted 6/2/2009 10:21 AM by hystericireul Xanga True Member - reply

Visit bigarnex's Xanga Site!

@hystericireul - 

明白,我都是香港人。不過也有一點:好似無人迫你生細路。
Posted 6/2/2009 1:57 PM by bigarnex Xanga True Member - reply

Visit galileo_c's Xanga Site!

@hystericireul - 你當我讀屎片就好,反正文化工業仍未夠開飯

Posted 6/3/2009 9:42 AM by galileo_c - reply

Visit Frostig's Xanga Site!

在香港我們會有這種職業流動性嗎?  


好問題,也正是我在面對的難題...... 


不是沒有,只要你有這樣的人脈,機會/空間/發展就會隨之而來;否則,哈哈......  作夢更容易呢!  


Posted 6/5/2009 12:48 PM by Frostig Xanga True Member - reply

Visit Frostig's Xanga Site!

@tommyjonk - 真是太好的提醒了!謝謝 Tommy Sir!  


@rabbitobaggio - 不只文科生吧?在香港,不是「揾食科目」就差不多都是「無用」(在很多香港人眼中)的了!  


Posted 6/5/2009 3:35 PM by Frostig Xanga True Member - reply


Choose Identity
(?)
 
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)



Back to hystericireul's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in hystericireul's local time zone:
GMT +08:00 (China Coast)
Site Meter

網誌排行 top-bloggers.com